What We Found in an Amazon Mystery Box: Unknown & More — May 14, 2026

This one came in at just over $500 in estimated retail value across 50 items, and honestly? It punched in a few unexpected directions. Not every box is a showstopper, but this one had a clear theme running through it once we dug in.

Twenty-Two Bags of Black Rifle Coffee Company Beyond Black Ground Coffee 1 pk — That's a Lot of Coffee

We're not exaggerating. Twenty-two sealed bags of Black Rifle Coffee Company Beyond Black Ground Coffee 1 pk at $12.99 each. That's the headline right there. Whether you stock up for yourself or grab a few bags as gifts, this is the kind of find that makes opening an Amazon Mystery Box worth every penny. Dark, bold, and ready to go.

Alongside all that coffee, we pulled six Everhard Shear and Knife Sharpener DM87765 Made in USA units at $11.50 each. Made in the USA, built for your kitchen shears and blades — these are the kind of practical tools that disappear fast off our shelves here in Hot Springs.

There was also a C-C Fast Charger for iPhone ($34.99 retail) and a ream of Basics Multipurpose Copy Printer Paper 8.5 x 11 Inch 20Lb 1 Ream | 500 Count (Sheets) 92 GE Bright White for the home office crowd. Nothing glamorous, but genuinely useful.

The rest of the haul — about 20 more pieces — is already sorted and heading into our store bins. Come dig through them in person if you're nearby.