What We Found in an Amazon Mystery Box: Optimum Nutrition & More — June 09, 2026

Two tubs of Optimum Nutrition Gold Standard 100% Whey Protein Powder Banana Cream 2 lb 29 Servings at $28.32 each. That alone almost covers the box. Our team opened this one on a Monday evening here in Hot Springs and the protein powder came out first — sealed, full size, ready for whoever's working on their summer goals.

Two Tubs of Optimum Nutrition Gold Standard Whey for Under $30 Each

Banana Cream flavor, 29 servings per tub, and both sealed. At retail that's $56.64 just for the pair — more than the cost of the whole Amazon Mystery Box. That's the kind of math that makes this hobby fun.

The rest of the box got weird in the best way. A New Strobe Emergency Light Color Pack of 4 showed up — useful, unexpected, and $24.99 retail. Then a Preserved Flower Arrangement in Wood Frame - Good Luck, also $24.99, which honestly looks like something you'd pay full price for at a boutique without blinking. Real preserved flowers in a wood frame. It's a genuinely nice gift item.

We also pulled two Meet the Moodies (MOM) 100% Silicone Sippy Cups with Straw & Handles from Fumiko — BPA-free, leak-proof, designed for babies 6 months and up. Both sealed, $10.99 each at retail. Good grab for any parent or grandparent shopping for a little one.

Beyond those named finds, there were plenty more bin-labeled items heading straight into our store bins for resale. Total estimated retail on the full box: $343.46. Not every box punches that hard, but this one did the work. Come find it at Deals Down Under in Hot Springs.