What We Found in an Amazon Mystery Box: NWSL & More — May 01, 2026

We cracked open an Amazon Mystery Box on May 1st and honestly? It delivered some genuine surprises. Thirty-seven items, around $279 in estimated retail value, and a few things that made the team stop and say wait, there are how many?

Twelve Sealed NWSL Trading Card Boxes — That's the Real Score Here

The standout find was a full dozen 2022 NWSL Women's Soccer Factory Sealed Trading Card Boxes — each one packed with 25 cards, 2 parallels, 3 inserts, and the possibility of autographs. Twelve of them. Factory sealed. At $10 each retail, that's a legitimately cool pull for any soccer fan or collector who wanders into our Hot Springs store. We don't usually see sports card inventory in these boxes, so this felt like a small jackpot.

Then there were twenty — yes, twenty — YAHTZEE Classic Dice Games. Shaker included, ages 8+, the real deal. Look, we love a good game night find, but twenty sets in a single box is a lot of Yahtzee energy for one afternoon. Every single one is brand new and sealed. They're headed straight to the floor.

Rounding things out: three E-Senior 30-piece Bronze Wall Mounted Coat Hook sets, each coming with 60 screws and ready for a bedroom, entryway, kitchen — wherever you need to hang something. Solid, practical, and honestly a nice little grab at under ten bucks retail.

Plus a couple of bin-labeled items heading into our store bins for the treasure hunters who love digging.

Not every Amazon Mystery Box is a dramatic reveal — but this one had variety, collectibles, and enough dice games to supply every game night in Garland County. Come see what's still on the shelf.