What We Found in an Amazon Mystery Box: Limited Run Games & More — May 22, 2026

Thursday's Amazon Mystery Box came in at 84 total items with an estimated retail value of $497.31. Not the flashiest box we've ever pulled in Hot Springs, but it had a solid rhythm to it — a lot of practical, everyday stuff, one genuinely fun surprise, and plenty more heading straight to our store bins.

The Best Find: A Sealed PS5 Copy of Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles: Shredder's Revenge

Tucked in among the supplements was a brand-new, sealed PlayStation 5 copy of Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles: Shredder's Revenge from Limited Run Games — retail $34.99. Limited Run prints these in small batches, so finding one sealed in a mystery box is legitimately a nice pull. Old-school beat-em-up energy, physical collector's copy. We were into it.

The health and wellness category absolutely dominated this one. There was a Culturelle Pro Strength Daily Probiotics (2-month supply, 60 count) at $30.99 retail, two units of Garden of Life Mykind Organics Women's Once Daily Multivitamin at $17.99 each, and a big 240-count bottle of Doctor's Best High Absorption Magnesium Tablets at $15.38. That's a solid little supplement haul on its own.

Then things got interesting in a very office-supply kind of way. Twelve — yes, twelve — Post-it Flags Value Packs came out of this box. Each pack runs $7.59 retail and includes 328 flags in assorted colors. That's $91.08 in sticky flags alone. We're not complaining, but someone out there was apparently very committed to organization.

Rounding out the notable items: eleven bottles of Nature Made Potassium Gluconate 550mg Tablets at $3.49 each, and twelve pouches of Nature's Recipe Grain Free Wet Dog Food at $1.21 each — plus dozens more bin-labeled items heading to our store bins.

Practical box. Real value. And a ninja turtle game that genuinely made our day.