What We Found in an Amazon Mystery Box: High Nest & More — May 17, 2026

We opened a small Amazon Mystery Box this evening, and while the total retail value clocked in at just under $145, this one was definitely more of a slow-burn kind of pull. Twenty-six items total, with twenty-five heading straight to our store bins — plus one standout piece worth talking about.

The Find: A High Nest Blue Pink Tumbler

Okay, so this isn't a box that's going to make anyone's jaw drop on paper. But that's kind of the charm of hunting these things in Hot Springs — sometimes you're not looking for a television. Sometimes you just want something pretty and functional that you didn't expect to find. The High Nest Blue Pink Tumbler is exactly that. Brand new, sealed, and honestly a great-looking piece at $19.99 retail. The color combo is genuinely striking — that soft blue and pink gradient has a lot of summer energy to it.

The rest of the box? Dozens of bin-labeled items now making their way into our store bins, where they'll find new homes at deep discounts. No complaints — that's part of the deal with mystery boxes, and our bins are looking fuller for it.

Not every Amazon Mystery Box is a jackpot. Some days you get the treasure, some days you feed the bins. Today we did a little of both — and we're totally okay with that.