What We Found in an Amazon Mystery Box: GNC & More — May 26, 2026

Sixty. That's how many Lilo & Stitch items came out of this one Amazon Mystery Box. We kept double-counting just to be sure. Stacked next to them: thirty-seven sealed packs of Oxford Ruled Index Cards, 3 x 5, White, 100/Pack at $4.99 each retail. That's a lot of back-to-school season covered in one pull.

The Standout: GNC AMP Wheybolic Clinically Proven Protein Powder at $69.99 Retail

This one sealed tub of GNC AMP Wheybolic Clinically Proven Protein Powder, 40g Whey Protein, BCAA, Leucine, Increases Muscle Strength, Muscle Building, 3rd Party Tested, Gluten Free, Natural Chocolate, 25 Servings nearly covers the cost of the whole box on its own. Brand new, sealed, $69.99 at retail. For a Hot Springs gym regular, that's a straight-up score.

Right behind it, the SEKETMAN 22PCS 1/2 Drive Shallow Impact Socket Set — a full metric set with extension bar, universal joint, and ratchet handle in CR-V steel. Thirty-five bucks retail, complete in the box. That's a real tool, not a throw-in.

Eight packs of Mommy's Bliss Gripe Water Original & Night Time Combo Pack showed up together — at $29.99 each retail, that's nearly $240 in baby care from one pull. Any parent who's done a 2am gripe water run knows exactly what this is worth. The Posh Setting Royal Collection White Plastic Plates With Silver & Royal Blue Design (40 plates total — 20 dinner, 20 salad) and a full bag of Molly's Suds Laundry Detergent Powder rounded out the household goods side nicely.

We also pulled a Febreze Plug Scent Booster Starter Kit Downy Calm, Bounty Napkins - White - 200ct, Milk-Bone Mini Comfort Chews Dog Treats, and a can of StarKist Solid White Albacore Tuna in Water. Not glamorous. Useful. The kind of everyday stuff that moves fast off our shelves.

Twenty-four commemorative car stickers marking the United States of America's 250th Anniversary made the cut too — a fun seasonal find. Plus dozens more bin-labeled items heading straight to our store bins.

Total estimated retail on this Amazon Mystery Box: $903.60. The box cost $55. We'll let that math speak for itself.