What We Found in an Amazon Mystery Box: Cream Tattoo Supply & More — May 29, 2026

This one clocked in at just over $1,000 in estimated retail value across 104 items total, and the mix was genuinely all over the place — in the best way. Hot Springs keeps us guessing, and so do these boxes.

Twenty-Five Hot Tamales Fierce Cinnamon 0.78 oz. Boxes — Yes, Twenty-Five

The candy haul alone made the team do a double-take. Twenty-five individual Hot Tamales Fierce Cinnamon 0.78 oz. Boxes at $15.50 a pop — that's $387.50 worth of fiery little candy sitting in one sealed Amazon Mystery Box. We've got them on the floor now, priced to move fast. If you've got a sweet tooth with a heat tolerance, come find us.

The rest of the notable finds were a little more unexpected. Two packs of Cream Tattoo Supply Gold Cartridges, 20pcs Japanese Steel Tattoo Needle Cartridges, Narrow Mag Housings for Tight Spaces (23 Magnum) showed up — professional-grade gear, sealed, $24.99 each retail. These are 23 Magnum cartridges built for tight spaces, and they're the kind of find that makes tattoo artists stop scrolling. Both packs are available in-store.

We also pulled a Daily Ritmo Paper Towel Holder White — simple, clean, functional — and a Coco Love Coconut Water with Pulp 12 Pack (11 fl oz cans) at $14.99 retail. Hydration and candy in the same box. Sure.

Beyond those, there were dozens more bin-labeled pieces heading straight into our store bins for resale. Plenty to dig through if you make it in.

Over $1,000 in retail value. One $55 Amazon Mystery Box. That math is why we keep opening these things.