What We Found in an Amazon Mystery Box: Coffeemate & More — June 13, 2026

We pulled this one on Friday evening and it gave us a little bit of everything — kitchen staples, classroom supplies, and tech accessories packed into a single sealed Amazon Mystery Box. Not the flashiest box we've ever opened here in Hot Springs, but it earned its keep.

The Hazelnut Trio That Made the Break Room Very Happy

Three boxes of Coffeemate 6 Pack Hazelnut Coffee Creamer came out first. At $16.00 retail each, that's $48 worth of creamer — six 16 fl oz bottles per box, twenty-four bottles total across the three. Our team did not hate this. If you've got a hazelnut habit, you know exactly how fast those go.

Alongside that, five GUNMJO Pro Custom Coiled USB-C to USB-A Cables in white. Five. At $13.99 each, that's nearly $70 in cables alone — coiled, custom, brand-new. These are the kind of accessory that disappears off our shelves quietly and quickly, and we've got a solid stack of them this time.

Rounding out the named finds: three Sktt Fraction Circles & Tiles Learning Sets, each packed with 156 thick foam pieces. At $14.99 a set, these are a genuinely solid grab for parents or teachers stocking up over the summer. Foam fraction manipulatives don't exactly scream "exciting unboxing," but a $45 retail value for hands-on math tools is nothing to skip past.

Beyond those eleven items, we pulled a dozen more bin-labeled pieces heading straight into our store bins for resale — so there's more to dig through if you make it in.

Total retail on this one clocked in at $232.92. The box cost $55. That math works out to just under $0.24 on the dollar, which lands this one solidly in the "worth it" column even if it's not the most glamorous haul we've ever done.