What We Found in an Amazon Mystery Box: Birkenstock & More — May 24, 2026

Let's be honest: not every Amazon Mystery Box is a home run. But this one? Pretty solid. Just over $597 in estimated retail across the notable pulls alone, and a handful of items that'll move fast off our shelves here in Hot Springs.

Three Pairs of Birkenstocks in One Box

Yeah, you read that right. Three Birkenstock Mayari 071791 Birko-flor Black Sandals — size 35, which runs about a women's 4 to 4.5 — came sealed inside this single box. At $100 retail each, that's $300 in footwear alone. They're the sleek toe-loop style with the classic Birko-flor upper. Whoever wears a size 4.5 in Hot Springs is about to have a very good day.

Beyond the Birkenstocks, we pulled six boxes of Super Beta Prostate Advanced Prostate Supplement for Men by New Vitality — the 60-caplet size, beta-sitosterol formula — at $31.99 each. That's nearly $192 in one supplement alone, and it's a well-reviewed product. Straight to the shelf, no questions asked.

We also grabbed two boxes of CELSIUS Dragonfruit Lime On The Go Energy Drink Mix, each a 14-pack of single-serve sticks at $11.24 retail. Easy grab for anyone who lives on the go. One Rejuvicare Liquid Collagen Beauty Formula rounded out the health and wellness haul — grape-flavored, 32 servings, loaded with amino acids, protein, and biotin. And yes, we also pulled two tubes of DAP Alex Plus Acrylic Latex Caulk, because mystery boxes don't care about your aesthetic preferences. Every box has its random moment.

Plus, there were a dozen more bin-labeled items heading straight into our store bins for resale — always worth a dig if you come in person.

All in all, this was a strong pull. The Birkenstocks alone justify the whole box. Keep watching — we open these regularly, and the next one could be even better.