What We Found in an Amazon Mystery Box: Anna & More — May 17, 2026

We opened this Amazon Mystery Box on May 17th and pulled 32 items total, clocking in at just over $440 in estimated retail value. Honestly? A decent mid-tier box. Nothing that made the whole room gasp, but a few things that made us smile — and one item that made us do a double-take.

Wait… Four Pounds of Pasta? The Surprise Find in This Box

Yes, really. Four sealed one-pound bags of ANNA, FUSILLI, ENRICHED MACARONI PRODUCT 1lb — at $45.51 each retail. That's nearly $182 in pasta alone. We've unboxed a lot of Amazon Mystery Boxes here in Hot Springs, and this is a first. Brand new, sealed, and honestly a little hilarious. They're in the store now if you need a pantry haul.

Beyond the carbs, the box had some genuinely fun stuff. The Hasbro Collectibles - Marvel Avengers - Titan Hero Series - 12" Deluxe Hulk Action Figure came in sealed at $22.98 retail — great grab for any Marvel household. We also pulled two Ethos Car Detail Spray - The Ultimate Quick Car Detailer for Car Shine & Protection - Enhances Gloss, Slickness & Hydrophobic Properties - Detailing Spray - Safe for Paint, Glass & Chrome bottles at $14.99 each, which always move fast with the car-care crowd.

Two boxes of Classic Boggle Word Search Game For Kids Ages 8 and Up came along for the ride — no link in our system yet, but they're on the shelf at $17.89 each. And if you're a tea person, two bags of Tea Better Kashmiri Kahwa Traditional Blend at $9.99 each are a really lovely find. Kashmiri Kahwa is warming, spiced, and a little floral — it's good stuff. Two Clay Sculpting Kits rounded things out, perfect for kids or a crafty afternoon.

The rest of the box — 19 bin-labeled pieces — are already headed into our store bins here in Hot Springs. Come dig around.