What We Found in an Amazon Mystery Box: Anna & More — May 17, 2026

Not every box we open is a home run, and this one sits somewhere in the fun-but-humble range — $296.86 estimated retail spread across a mixed bag that made the team do a few double-takes. The pasta alone raised some eyebrows.

Two Pounds of ANNA, FUSILLI, ENRICHED MACARONI PRODUCT 1lb at $45.51 Each

Yes, pasta. Premium pasta. We pulled two sealed 1lb bags of ANNA, FUSILLI, ENRICHED MACARONI PRODUCT 1lb out of this Amazon Mystery Box — $45.51 each at retail, which means this fusilli accounts for over $91 of the box's total value all by itself. We're not judging. We're just saying: it's some very serious pasta.

The next surprise was a lot more colorful. The Hasbro Collectibles - Marvel Avengers - Titan Hero Series - 12" Deluxe Hulk Action Figure came out sealed, retail tagged at $22.98. A solid pull for any kid — or, let's be real, any adult with a shelf to fill.

From there the box got genuinely useful. The Ethos Car Detail Spray - The Ultimate Quick Car Detailer for Car Shine & Protection - Enhances Gloss, Slickness & Hydrophobic Properties - Detailing Spray - Safe for Paint, Glass & Chrome at $14.99 retail is the kind of thing you'd just pick up anyway. Same goes for the Tea Better Kashmiri Kahwa Traditional Blend — a $9.99 aromatic loose-leaf find that felt a little unexpected in the best way. And the Clay Sculpting Kit at $9.99 is a perfect bin grab for a parent hunting weekend activities on a budget.

Classic Boggle — the word search game for ages 8 and up at $17.89 retail — rounded out the notable finds. A classic that never really gets old, especially for family game nights here in Hot Springs.

Beyond those, the box had plenty of bin-labeled items heading straight into our store bins. All available in-store while they last.